Schalk Burger and Kevin Foote question several officiating decisions that may have cost the Springboks victory at the Stade de France on Friday.
The Bok legend and Junior Springboks coach on the Boks Unpacked X The Verdict podcast reviewed the controversial moments from South Africa’s 21-19 loss in Paris.
These included five yellow cards and a 20-minute red card for Bok No 8 Jasper Wiese, along with a deliberate knock-on by France winger Aaron Grandidier-Nkanang and a disallowed Kurt-Lee Arendse try by TMO Matteo Liperini.
Rassie Erasmus risks the ire of World Rugby for his comments about Les Bleus committing 17 knee-drop tackles without sanction, while referee Andrea Piardi’s handling of the scrum infringements has left much to be desired.
MORE: Kiwis call out Rassie’s ‘bulls**t’
“When last did the attacking team get a try disallowed for breaking the 10m line?” Burger asked. “As a TMO, you decide to come in there. But where there’s absolutely zero tolerance on knee drops and hip drops … Nothing. It just doesn’t quite sit well with me.
“[Piardi] just bailed out of the [scrum] contest. You can’t have a 5m scrum, the scrum’s been one-way traffic, put the French on a team warning. Then after that, give a penalty and say, ‘OK, that’s not a team warning, because he can’t figure out the individual’. Yes, it was. It was No 18, and it was the tighthead.
“And then after that, the same picture happens again. And then you say, ‘No, but now we’ve got to play away, because it’s now not a penalty the fifth time’. I don’t quite get it.”
MCKENZIE: No use moaning about KLA’s try
Foote added: “I agree with Schalk; he [Piardi] had put them on a warning. And I thought Rassie was helluva mature and humble in his post-match. He said we’re human, we make mistakes, and maybe we shouldn’t have gone for the scrum.
“Our strategy is we’re going to scrum you, and we didn’t get the reward. When he said team warning, of course we’re going to go for the scrum.
“You can argue, why don’t you go maul? The reality is it’s our weapon.”
PLUS: Why Irish prop wasn’t banned for ‘ball grab’
Photo: Florencia Tan Jun/Getty Images
The post KLA’s ‘no try’ doesn’t sit well with Schalk appeared first on SA Rugby magazine.
Schalk Burger and Kevin Foote question several officiating decisions that may have cost the Springboks victory at the Stade de France on Friday.
The post KLA’s ‘no try’ doesn’t sit well with Schalk appeared first on SA Rugby magazine. Read More



