Why Irish prop wasn’t banned for ‘ball grab’

The URC has finally released the 22-page full written verdict from Tadhg Furlong’s disciplinary hearing.

The Leinster and Ireland prop was cited after allegedly grabbing Munster No 8 Gavin Coombes’ testicles during a breakdown cleanout at the Aviva Stadium on 24 October.

However, an independent disciplinary committee cleared Furlong following a hearing on 28 October, allowing him to face the Springboks in Dublin on Saturday.

The decision sparked accusations of double standards among South Africans, with Bulls hooker Jan-Hendrik Wessels having received a nine-week ban, later reduced to eight, for a similar offence involving Connacht’s Josh Murphy.

RASSIE: I don’t think they sleep well at night

The written verdict explains why the committee dismissed the complaint against Furlong.

Coombes told the hearing he had felt Furlong’s hand between his legs before experiencing a firm squeeze lasting two to three seconds.

Furlong denied grabbing Coombes’ testicles, explaining that he had been attempting a legitimate breakdown cleanout by hooking his opponent’s leg. He insisted his hand had been cupping Coombes’ upper thigh to generate leverage rather than gripping his genitals.

Crucially, the committee found that close-up still images and slow-motion footage supported Furlong’s explanation.

“On first viewing, the video footage appeared to be consistent with the allegation,” the verdict stated.

However, closer examination of the footage and frame-by-frame stills changed that assessment.

“The committee found that the firm squeeze of two to three seconds described by Mr Coombes could not have occurred.”

RASSIE: Is that not match-fixing?

The committee concluded that Furlong’s hand position was more consistent with his account than with the allegation.

The committee accepted that Coombes had given an honest account and had not deliberately embellished his evidence. However, it offered an alternative explanation for the pressure he experienced.

“The most likely cause of what Mr Coombes felt: a static, all-round pressure arising from his own legs closing around the player’s arm, rather than from any grip by the player’s hand.”

ALSO: Rassie in hot water again

The committee also attached little weight to conflicting accounts of an alleged post-match verbal exchange between the players.

Having determined that Furlong had not grabbed, squeezed or twisted Coombes’ testicles, the committee ruled that the question of recklessness did not arise.

The citing complaint was therefore not upheld.

The post Why Irish prop wasn’t banned for ‘ball grab’ appeared first on SA Rugby magazine.

The URC has finally released the 22-page full written verdict from Tadhg Furlong’s disciplinary hearing.
The post Why Irish prop wasn’t banned for ‘ball grab’ appeared first on SA Rugby magazine. Read More

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *